I consider All the Presidents Men to be one the most well directed films ever. The scene below is a great example of that, I’ll focus mostly on the later scene where he sits at his desk making phone calls.
[yframe url='http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DLTTW9tDkfk']
In film school we had a research exercise called ”the natural story” where we went out and observed people at their workplaces. The main goal was to nail down character traits specific for the job we were observing, later on we would implement these traits on our fictional characters for that project. This scene is a great example of this kind of approach. Redford totally feels like a reporter and it very subtle and not the cliché (this character times ten) that we have come to got used to.
Acting wise I’m especially fond of how Redford listens during the phone calls and his reactions to the surroundings (background noise and interfering colleague). The sequence when he switch between the incoming calls is brilliant in all its simplicity.
I also want to bring up the other elements in the scene. The cinematography simply documents the scene without trying to be glossy or picture perfect. I really like how simple it looks but when you look closer on it you can see how well thought out it is. There are several times when we don’t see what Redford is looking at which I find interesting, instead we see his reaction to it. There is also nice use of depth of field that enhances the background. On to editing and sound.
Wow! I’m not doing a clip count but I sure wish a lot of directors, editors, and cinematographers would be inspired by this kind of pacing. I find it very suspenseful in its context. I haven’t seen the film in years but was totally drawn into the scene and the seriousness of it. I think this comes mostly from the use of a static long take. The sound design is also really good, its subtle but you could still listen in to whats happening in the background if you wanted to focus on that. Finally, isn’t it nice to NOT have a score that tells you how you should feel when listening to it?
There is a lot to learn from this.
Poll Quickie: As you can see both Dog Day Afternoon and Moon are eating up the percentage towards Long Kiss Goodnight so if you haven’t gotten your votes in yet its time for that now!
{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }
Cool post. I like how you dissected each part of the scene
My favorite scene for me is from Eyes Wide Shut.
Thanks Julian, I would actually want to do an analysis of the pool (billiard) scene in Eyes Wide. Unfortunately its not on YouTube.
Interesting thoughts Joel, I like your analysis of this scene.
It’s clear that this style of filmmaking just isn’t done much anymore, which is a shame really as I like it a lot.
Also I really dislike those scores designed to provoke a certain kind of emotion from the audience, I find it very manipulative and slightly annoying, surely if the director was talented he could evoke emotion through a combination of the visuals and the score without it being unpleasant to the audience…
Anyway, I like this idea for a post and will be checking out all your upcoming ones.
Thanks Jack. The brilliance here is going without a score at all during such a tense moment. Today that probably would be considered insane if doing a mainstream film (not Indie).
Interesting…I never look at a movie with that kind of detail. I love how you specify it clearly.
If you only give me the video, I wouldn’t understand what to look for
I know but isin’t that fun? I love to dissect films that I generally like a lot to try to understand what makes them so good or at least make me like them so much.
Even if you didn’t know what to look for you must admit its a good scene especially when its being pulled completely out of context like this.
I haven’t seen that movie yet. One of the big hole in my movie watching adventures. Excellent analysis of this scene though, there is so much layer and details that skilled actors can add to a scene and a movie that can go unnoticed by many people.
You are in for a treat when you decide to watch it. Its one of the most underrated films ever. There are a ton of brilliant scenes that could be analyzed in a similar way.
I am sure I commented here….tut tut….Ah well
Great post as ever Joel, you are such a clever sausage!!
Hahaha I’ll take that as a compliment then. The Swedish film sausage of knowledge.
I never thought about the lack of score. Maybe I should rewatch this.
I also love how this movie is all about listening. The way Woowdard cocks his head and says ‘Holy shit’ to the first non-hearing bout the Watergate scandal, or how Bernstein’s eyes pay attention to Jane Alexander’s character and her reluctance in sharing what she knows.
I couldn’t agree more with you the entire film is a 130 minutes showdown of great minimalistic acting. I could the same kind of deep analysis on at least ten more scenes in the film. Its terribly underrated when it comes to acting, directing, cinematography and even sound design as I briefly touch on here.